The Big Dance - 2008
Ask a Kentucky Wildcat fan, I am obliged to start this blog by saying, “Whew!” I thought the Cats were out of luck when Georgia stole a bid. They probably won’t last long, but I’m glad they are in.
Ok, back to the main body of the blog…
First - the Mid-Majors. For so many years the mid-majors have been whining about their being overlooked in the NCAA tournament. All the talking heads jump on the bandwagon after the famous George Mason run to the Final Four, and they start rambling about parity in Division 1 basketball. It must be having some effect because now we see teams like Butler and Drake ranked in the top 25. Not even five years ago if either one of these guys were undefeated at this point in the season and they still wouldn’t crack the top 25.Â
I’m not saying I agree with teams that dominate a mid-major conference getting a top-25 ranking. I’m just making the observation. To me, it takes a lot more than some inexplicably long runs into the tournament to say that teams like Butler and conferences like the Horizon, Missouri Valley and Sun Belt are truly, sustainably as good as major teams and conferences. I chalk up the George Mason anomoly to the fact that it was bound to happen eventually. And the fact that the tension and excitement of the Big Dance puts a lot of pressure on favorites.
So Butler comes in to the tournament as a 7-seed and now the whiners and talking heads are complaining they have to play another mid-major in the first round! Give me a break! You can’t have your cake and eat it too! The cake is that Butler has earned some respect, they got the 7-seed. The eating it too would be to expect the committee to give a darn about who they play in the first round.Â
Next topic - expansion of the tournament. I don’t really understand why this is such a fascination for hoops experts. Expanding the NCAA tournament would be one of the dumbest moves imaginable. And I would even say that if Kentucky were playing in the NIT tonight instead of the NCAA tournament on Thursday.
The NCAA tournament is wildly popular because it is pure and simple, it is unforgiving, and it is conclusive. To get in, it is simple - win games. If you end up on the bubble, and then you get cut out - too bad, you should have won one more game. As tournements go, and as a means of deciding a national champion, it is in a word - perfect. To monkey with it would be beyond stupid.
I love the annual discussion of the automatic bids, the bubble and the snubs. Expanding the tournament to 128 certainly would end the bubble discussions by making the bubble discussions completely inane. But not everything that causes anxiety and tension has to be stopped. The bubble discussions and white knuckled build-up to Selection Sunday is great! Who would want it to end?
I’m sure the folks who came up with the BCS would love to see the NCAA tournament expanded because then they would no longer be the biggest fools in college sports.
I’m not a big Carolina fan but I believe they are the best team in the country and most likely to win the whole thing. Second best team is Kansas, who unfortunately find themselves in a position of needing to beat Carolina to get to the final. We will see!










